The Guardian
The Guardian Friday, August 16, 2002


George Monbiot: Is an elite secret society undermining the impartiality of Scottish justice?

The Skye bridge club

For several years the people of Skye have had the sense that they were being treated unjustly.  In 1989, the government decided that the bridge between their island and the mainland would be funded not publicly but privately.  The developers would reclaim their costs with a road toll.

The toll turned out to be the highest per mile of road in the world.  The private consortium invested just £500,000, from which it is due to reap some £88m from the people of Skye.

Many of the islanders refused to pay.  They argued that the paperwork legalising the road tolls had never been published.  Scotland's foremost legal expert, Professor Robert Black, described the government's demand that the tolls be paid as "fatally flawed".

The fatal flaw, however, did not stop the prosecution of 496 of the islanders.  Some of them appealed, but their arguments were dismissed by Scotland's law lords.  Many observers, including some very eminent lawyers, criticised the law lords' decisions.  Some of the islanders began to question the impartiality of the courts.

Now, research by the tireless campaigner Robbie the Pict, published here for the first time, reveals that many of the key decision-makers, in and out of the courts, belong to a society which keeps its membership secret.

The Speculative SocietyLINK, which is housed in the University of Edinburgh, appears to have arisen from a masonic guild in the 18th centuryLINK.  Three hundred years ago, the "operative" masons from the building trade began to admit "speculative" members, who were people of high standing from outside the trade.LINK

The Edinburgh Speculative Society later split from the operative masons, to concentrate on cementing the bonds between powerful people.  Unlike freemasons, the "knights" of the society, who are all male and all white, do not swear an oath of loyalty to each other.

Their meetings appear to concentrate on dining and debate.  The group describes itself as a "sodality", or brotherhood, and its motto urges the "brethren... in unity to dwell".  That is about the limit of what nonmembers can discover.  Even the University of Edinburgh, whose principal is an honorary memberLINK, claims never to have heard of it.

But the secret membership lists obtained by the Pict show that many of the most powerful people in Scotland have received either "extraordinary privileges" or "honorary privileges" from the society.  Among them are the Duke of Edinburgh (membership number 1662LINK), Lord Mackay of Clashfern, the former British lord chancellor (no 1676LINK), many of Scotland's leading company directors, several top surgeons, journalists and academics, plenty of sheriffs and QCs and at least 18 Scottish law lords.

The Pict alleges that the law lords' membership of the society throws the impartiality of many of the key Skye bridge cases into serious doubt.  Over the past six years, Scottish law lords have presided over 14 hearings involving the bridge protesters.  In every case they have ruled against the protesters and in favour of the crown and the toll collectors.

In 12 of these hearings, one or more of the law lords presiding over them and the government officials or company directors whose arguments they have assessed have, the secret lists reveal, been members of the Speculative Society.  In Anderson v Hingston 1996, for example, Lords MorisonLINK and WeirLINK, who are listed as enjoying the "extraordinary privileges" of the secret brotherhood, sat in judgment on a case concerning the legality of a decision made by the Minister of Transport, Lord James Douglas-Hamilton.  Lord Douglas-Hamilton is also a member of the society (no 1772).LINK

Appeals by the protesters concerning Lord Douglas-Hamilton's decisions were later examined by Lords CowieLINK, CoulsfieldLINK, MarnochLINK, MacLeanLINK, JohnstonLINK, Drummond YoungLINK, Nimmo SmithLINK, Cameron of LochbroomLINK and the lord justice-general Lord Cullen (no 1702LINK), all of whom belong to the Speculative Society.  In Robbie the Pict v Miller Civil Engineering and the Secretary of State, 1998, the government was represented by a QC called Duncan Menzies (now Lord Menzies), another knight of the Speculative SocietyLINK.  The case was heard by his fellow knights Lords Cameron and Johnston.

In January this year, Lord Drummond Young prevented an appeal brought by Robbie the Pict against a judgment of Lord Johnston's.  In May, Lord MacLean helped to judge Robbie the Pict's petition against a decision made by Lord Cullen.  All four law lords are members of the brotherhood.  The 496 Skye defendants were all refused legal aid. There may have been good grounds for refusal, but if so these were not explained.  Standing counsel to the legal aid board from 1991-98 was Colin McEachran QC, also a member of the societyLINK.

The body with overall responsibility for making the Skye bridge project happen was the Scottish Office's development department.   One of its senior officials was Niall Campbell, another knight of the societyLINK.  He went on to run the Scottish Office's justice department.  The tolls on the bridge are collected by the Skye Bridge Company.  Its chairman was Sir Iain Noble.  He too belongs to the societyLINK.

Since July 1999, Scottish law has been, in principle, legally compliant with the European convention on human rights.  Article six of the convention determines that "everyone is entitled to a fair and public hearing within a reasonable time by an independent and impartial tribunal".  "Independent and impartial" means, in this case, above any reasonable public suspicion of influence or special interest.  Robbie the Pict suggests that the law lords' adjudication of cases involving other members of the Speculative Society appears to offend both the letter and the spirit of the law.  Interestingly, an essay published in 1968 in the official history of the Speculative Society by Sir Derrick Dunlop (a former president of the society) observes that "we all know... that the judicature is icy in its impartiality, which is one of the chief glories of this country, but perhaps this impartiality would be strained to breaking point where the Speculative is concerned".

Whether this demonstrates partiality or not is impossible to say.  Not every judge in the Skye bridge cases is a member of the society   [Ed ~ No, but it was suspiciously overloaded with them.LINK]  There is no evidence that anyone has exploited his links with other members of the society.  [Ed ~ Nor is there evidence to the contrary.]  But when Lord Hoffman's membership of Amnesty International was revealed, soon after he and his fellow law lords decided that General Augusto Pinochet should be extradited to Spain, the original judgment had to be scrapped and a retrial ordered.  Amnesty International had no direct connection with the prosecution.  In this case there is a direct connection between the law lords and the people whose decisions they were assessing.  Their undeclared membership of the society surely necessitates a retrial of all the cases involving Skye bridge.

But that is not the end of the matter.  These law lords have, between them, presided over thousands of other hearings.  The Pict's findings raise questions about the entire system of Scottish law, and should also cause those of us living south of the border to take a closer look at our own system.  Public confidence in the law requires that the judiciary be above suspicion.  This story suggests that we cannot be assured that this is so.

Transcript taken from The Guardian Friday August 16, 2002

Copyright © 2016 William Burns. All rights reserved.
Albert einstein
Dunblane Whitewash
Dunblane City Sign
Scotland Map


Dunblane Public Inquiry
Dunblane Massacre
Read the full list in the Dunblane Whitewash catalogue. LINK
Dunblane Angels
St Blane's Church Dunblane
The stained glass window in St Blane's Church, Dunblane, which commemorates the victims of the 1996 massacre.
List of the victims of the Dunblane massacre
Victoria Clydesdale
Mhairi MacBeath
Charlotte Dunn
Melissa Currie
Emma Crozier
Kevin Hassell
Ross Irvine
David Kerr
Gwen Hodson/Mayor - schoolteacher
John Petrie
Hanna Scott
Joanna Ross
Sophie North
Emily Morton
Maegan Turner
Brett McKinnon
Abigail McLennan
We know who killed the above victims, but, although we may not care, we do not know for sure who killed Thomas Hamilton, and why that person was carrying a revolver at the time!
Why did Lord Cullen try to bury William Burns' letters to him for 100 years? LINK